| Year | Junior Breeder | Senior Breeder | Year | Junior Breeder | Senior Breeder |
| 1970 | Wayne Specht | Ira Lee | 2006 | Lamar Liming | Bill Ramsey* |
| 1971 | Charles Duncan | Eugene Welch | 2007 | Kurt & Rachel Topp | Walter & Regina Berg |
| 1972 | James Kemp | Clark Biddle | 2008 | Nevin L’Amoreaux | Bob Ackley |
| 1973 | Carleton Weiker | Walter Johnson | 2009 | Joe Cole | Ted Renner |
| 1974 | Karl Havens | Floyd Carter | 2010 | Jay & Kristy Ackley | John & Suzanne Lora |
| 1975 | Dale Ring | E.D. Rausch | 2011 | Jeremy Adams | Jim Sheffield |
| 1976 | William Conklin | Ignatius Cavanagh | 2012 | Eric Topp | Terry Stammen |
| 1977 | Robert Haskins | Horace Stewart | 2013 | Russell Kiko III | Mary Lou Topp |
| 1978 | Hugh Knoop | Paul Ramsey | 2014 | Adam Whiteleather | Tom Thorbahn |
| 1979 | Marvin Topp | Gerlad Hoepf | 2015 | Pine Tree Dairy / Steiner Family | Richard Indoe |
| 1980 | John Spreng Jr. | Lowell Geringer | 2016 | Phillip Topp | Lawrence Whiteleather |
| 1981 | Carl Lund | Carl Miller | 2017 | Rudy Kiko | Dean Zimmer |
| 1982 | Bill Ramsey | Leory Leininger | 2018 | Charlie Henry | David Klingensmith |
| 1983 | Loren Elsass | John Schlenker | 2019 | Jason Miley | Steve Buschur |
| 1984 | Don Topp | Norbert DeLoye | 2020 | Evan Kiko | Jon Miley |
| 1985 | Larry Gortner | James Lewis | 2021 | Ben Simpson | Doug Dye |
| 1986 | Jim Spreng | Ralph Rigg | 2022 | Ty Etgen | Jay & Kristy Ackley* |
| 1987 | Jeff Hoepf | Karl Havens* | 2023 | Damon Bertke | Bill Indoe* |
| 1988 | Terry Weiker | William McKarns | 2024 | Ryan Welch | Rodney Campbell |
| 1989 | John Carmichael | Sterling TImmons | 2025 | Chad Griffith | Triple-T Holsteins |
| 1990 | None | Mike Yarosh | |||
| 1991 | Kevin Miller | John Spreng Sr. | |||
| 1992 | Tom Strasburg | Glenn Mutchler | |||
| 1993 | Marvin Steinke | Darl Whims | |||
| 1994 | Duane Logan | George D. Logan | |||
| 1995 | None | Waldo Imbrock | |||
| 1996 | None | None | |||
| 1997 | Mark W. Henry | Carl W. Lund* | |||
| 1998 | None | Maynard Bingamon | |||
| 1999 | Don Simpson | Dick Lewis | |||
| 2000 | Joe Miley | Jim Kemp | |||
| 2001 | Randy Rausch | Tom Lang | |||
| 2002 | William Indoe | Morris Van Gorden | |||
| 2003 | Chris Lang | Howard Moff | |||
| 2004 | Daryl Duncan | John Spreng Jr.* | |||
| 2005 | Eric Havens | John Hartline | |||
* Awarded both Junior and Senior Breeder